Difference between revisions of "No limits fallacy"

From Imperial Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
m
 
(5 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
The '''no limits fallacy''' is the [[Logical fallacy|illogical idea]] that a poorly understood phenomenon can be extrapolated to infinity or assumed to not have any maximum value or threshold.  For a gross example, observing that a [[shield]] can easily withstand an attack from a particular weapon, one might illogically conclude that the shield could withstand fire from an unlimited number of those weapons at the same time, or that it could withstand fire from a similar weapon that was much more powerful.
The '''no limits fallacy''' is the [[Logical fallacy|illogical idea]] that a poorly understood phenomenon can be extrapolated to infinity or assumed not to have any maximum value or threshold.  For a gross example, observing that a [[shield]] can easily withstand an attack from a particular weapon, one might illogically conclude that the shield could withstand fire from an unlimited number of those weapons at the same time, or that it could withstand fire from a similar weapon that was much more powerful.


== Examples ==
== Trekkie Examples ==
* The [[no laser fallacy]]: if small, technologically inferior ship cannot hurt the ''Enterprise'' with its lasers, the NO laser can.
* The [[no laser fallacy]]: if a small, technologically inferior ship cannot hurt the ''Enterprise'' with its lasers, then NO laser can hurt a Federation starship.
* [[Reverse engineering]]: if the Federation can obtain a sample of alien technology, they can rapidly reproduce it.
* [[Reverse engineering]]: if the Federation can obtain a sample of alien technology, they can rapidly reproduce it, no matter how much more advanced it is than their own.
* [[Borg]] [[Borg adaptation|adaptation]] and assimilation: if a Borg cube can negate the weapons of one Federation starship after adapting, it can negate ANY weapon via adaptation.
* [[Borg]] [[Borg adaptation|adaptation]]: if a Borg cube can negate the weapons of one Federation starship after adapting, it can negate ANY weapon via adaptation.
* Borg invasion of other dimensions: since the Borg attempted to invade the home dimension of Species 8472, they must have already invaded and successfully assimilated multiple other dimensions.
* Borg invasion of other dimensions: since the Borg attempted to invade the home dimension of [[Species 8472]], they must have already invaded and successfully assimilated multiple other dimensions.


[[Category: debate]]
[[Category: debate]]
[[Category: Trekkie Arguments]]
[[Category: Trekkie Arguments]]

Latest revision as of 18:52, 3 November 2022

The no limits fallacy is the illogical idea that a poorly understood phenomenon can be extrapolated to infinity or assumed not to have any maximum value or threshold. For a gross example, observing that a shield can easily withstand an attack from a particular weapon, one might illogically conclude that the shield could withstand fire from an unlimited number of those weapons at the same time, or that it could withstand fire from a similar weapon that was much more powerful.

Trekkie Examples

  • The no laser fallacy: if a small, technologically inferior ship cannot hurt the Enterprise with its lasers, then NO laser can hurt a Federation starship.
  • Reverse engineering: if the Federation can obtain a sample of alien technology, they can rapidly reproduce it, no matter how much more advanced it is than their own.
  • Borg adaptation: if a Borg cube can negate the weapons of one Federation starship after adapting, it can negate ANY weapon via adaptation.
  • Borg invasion of other dimensions: since the Borg attempted to invade the home dimension of Species 8472, they must have already invaded and successfully assimilated multiple other dimensions.