Minimalism

From ImperialWiki
Revision as of 07:06, 31 March 2010 by Zor (Talk | contribs)
(diff) ← Older revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)
Jump to: navigation, search

Minimalism is the use of numbers that seem absurdly low for the situation/universe. This is a common brain bug, and one such example of minimalism run amok is is the so-called "3 million troopers" franchise decision in Star Wars. In a galaxy with at least a million worlds as part of the primary political entity, 3 million soldiers are entirely insufficient to fight a war on a pan-galactic scale. Other examples include the 200 vessel 'Katana' fleet in the Thrawn Trilogy, and the numbers provided for the majority of the battles during the Yuuzhan Vong invasion.

Star Wars isn't the only guilty franchise, though.

Contents

Why is this important?

While one could never call a space opera "realistic" certain things are expected. Tens of millions of men and women were mobilized during WW2, and no matter the level of technology, a certain number of "boots on the ground" would be required for any successful occupation.

For example, while an orbiting starship may be able to bombard the planetary government into submission, there may still be widespread partisan activity. In addition, if the planet has economic resources (be they industrial or natural) it would be necessary to land troops and attempt to seize the facilities intact instead of risking destroying them from orbit. All these things mean a large number of troops would be needed to fight planetary, inter-planetary, or intra-galactic conflicts.

Why do EU authors prefer minimalist stories?

In the decision to concentrate on a handful of characters in the SW franchise, most EU authors seem to have opted to minimize the importance of the greater universe. After all, with trillions, possibly quadrillions, of people out there, it's hard to argue that a smuggler and a farmboy (even if he is a Jedi) are the be-all, end-all to everything important that happens.

Alternatively, some authors may simply be unable to write to the numbers. Most EU material has been written during the immediate Post-Cold War Era of Operation Desert Storm and the operations in the Balkans, and the common layperson has come to equate a high-tech military with a minimal amount of ground troops. Whatever their talents as writers may be, most EU authors are laypeople who very rarely, if ever, give much thought to how the military really works.

Another possibility is that the author simply cannot conceive of the real implications of the mind-boggling scale of pan-galactic civilization, as evidenced by numbers up to a dozen orders of magnitude too low. Again, however talented they may otherwise be, most EU authors rarely give much thought to how a true pan-galactic civilization would really function.

A fourth possibility is simple hack writing, with the author throwing in a tiny force out of sheer laziness and declaring it a massive threat due to the perceived need to have everything occur on a galactic scale.

Other Examples of Minimalism

  • In Star Trek, the Romulans once attempted to invade Vulcan with a mere 2000 troops.
  • The Imperial Space Marines of Warhammer 40,000 are claimed to be able to conduct planetary-scale operations with just 1000 marines.
  • In Battletech, the Clans launched an invasion against the thousands of worlds and trillions of the Inner Sphere with a force of less than 100,000 warriors.

External Links

Personal tools